

| Legion of Honor | |||
| 1975 | Milo A. Rediger '39 | 1993 | Billy A. Melvin '51 |
| 1978 | Harold J. Ockenga '27 | 1994 | Conrad Rehling '43 |
| 1980 | Ted W. Engstrom '38 | 1995 | Jay L. Kesler '58 |
| 1983 | Don J. Odle '42 | 1998 | George A. Glass '58 |
| 1985 | Elmer N. Nussbaum '49 | 1999 | Jared Gerig '29 |
| 1986 | Samuel F. Wolgemuth '38 | 2004 | Paul Robbins '60 |
| 1988 | Walter C. Randall '38 | 2006 | Wesley L. Gerig '51 |
| 1989 | Ralph E. Dodge, Sr. '31 | 2009 | Char (Miller) Binkley '65 |
| 1991 | Paul D. Clasper '44 | ||
| Distinguished Young Alumnus(a) for Personal Achievement | |||
| 2000 | Amy (Level) Warren '92 | 2008 | Corey Laster '93 |
| 2001 | Ken Hogg '85 | 2009 | Lindsey (Carpenter) Arthur '01 |
| 2005 | Dawn Kale '87 | Josh Arthur '01 | |
| Distinguished Young Alumnus(a) for Professional Achievement | |||
| 2004 | Brian Hudson '91 | 2008 | Shani (Gray) Wilfred'99 |
| 2007 | Andy Booth '02 | 2009 | Erica (Williams) Hanson '03 |
| Distinguished Alumnus(a) for Personal Achievement | ||||||||
| 2002 | Tom Rust '72 | 2008 | Mabel Bahler '70 | |||||
| 2003 | Marilyn (Dissinger) Steiner '63 | 2009 | Paul Erdel '48 | |||||
| 2005 | Phil '68 and Jan (Schumacher) '67 Logan | 2009 | Paul Erdel '48 | |||||
| 2006 | Richard '70 and Cheri (Bruhner) '73 Armstrong | Sharon Ayabe '86 | 2007 | Matt Hartsell ‘81 | 2011 | Don '48 and Faythe (Ringenberg) '48 Rohrs | ||
| Distinguished Alumnus(a) for Professional Achievement | |||||
| Until 2001, the FW Council gave the awards below under different names. | |||||
| 1999 | Phil '74 and Fran Mortensen h'99 - Distinguished Alumni for Urban Ministry |
2003 | Eric Wiggin '63 | ||
| 1999 | Quinton J. Everest '28 - Distinguished Alumnus for Lifetime Achievement |
2004 | Jay Platte '69 | ||
| 2000 | Arthur '45 & Gladys (Chapman) '45 Reifel - Distinguished Alumni for Missionary Service |
2005 | Calvin J. Rychener '81 | ||
| 2000 | Loyal R. Ringenberg '28FW/'30UP - Distinguished Alumnus for Lifetime Achievement |
2006 | Todd Habegger '76 | ||
| 2001 | Steve Morley '65 | 2009 | Lee Underwood '86 | ||
| 2002 | Dennis Magary '73 | 2011 | David Stout '60 | ||
| Chamber of Service |
| Distinguished Alumnus(a) for Service to Taylor University Fort Wayne | |||||
| 1997 | Gerald '45 and Violet (Egly) '45 Ringenberg | 2005 | Jeff Gerig '84 | ||
| 2002 | Sarita Rubrake '92 | 2007 | Mr. Max and Mable Poorman | ||
| 2002 | Joy Gerig '52, '66 | 2008 | Cyril Eicher '32 | ||
| 2003 | Richard Baxter '70 | 2009 | Jackie Carl '53 | ||
| 2004 | Lowell Burrus '74 | 2011 | Timothy "Tim" Erdel '73 | ||
| Distinguished Friend | |||
| 1996 | Mary Edith Reiff | 2006 | Mark and Cindy Deister |
| 1997 | Paul and Ruth Steiner | 2008 | Jerry B. Jenkins |
| 2003 | Dan and Jude Wells | ||
| Honorary Alumnus(a) | |||
| 1975 | J. Francis Chase | 2005 | Tami Solak |
| 1980 | Jonas A. Ringenberg | 2006 | Russell R. Rogers |
| Ira A. Gerig | 2007 | Lee Oliver | |
| 1987 | Robin Howard | 2008 | Dennis Hensley |
| 1993 | Ken Swan | 2009 | Aimee Betsui |
| 1995 | Eunice Conrad | Dr. Michael Cook | |
| Ted and Rose Ann Nickel | Rick Dietiker | ||
| 1996 | Mary Edith Reiff | Ruth Elder | |
| 1998 | Robert Nienhuis | Anita Gray | |
| 1999 | Fran Mortensen | Ardonna "AJ" Jackson | |
| 2001 | Sherri R. Harter | Jane Janovyak | |
| 2002 | Don Hamm | Dr. Duane and Mrs. Joni Kilty | |
| 2004 | Ron Sloan | Michele (Mallett) Wells | |
| Katherine (Haywood) Miranda | |||
| Anthony (Tony) Opliger | |||
| Dr. James and Mrs. Agnes Saddington | |||
| Dr. John Schutt | |||
| Caroline Simmons | |||
| Dr. Steve Smith | |||
| Heather St. Peters | |||
| Jerry "JT" Toor | |||
| Joe Updegrove | |||
| Mike Van Huisen | |||
| Evan Wood | |||